In an era where servant leadership is often hailed as the gold standard, it’s essential to recognize that no one style fits all situations, especially in periods of geopolitical uncertainty or organizational crisis. While the compassionate, people-first approach of servant leadership has many merits, it may not always be what’s needed in times of significant challenges. Let’s explore the nuances of leadership styles and why adaptability is crucial, particularly when the stakes are high.

The Appeal of Servant Leadership

Servant leadership focuses on the growth and well-being of people and the communities to which they belong. This leadership style is characterized by a leader who is primarily service-oriented, prioritizing the needs of the team members and encouraging a collaborative, inclusive work environment. In stable conditions or in industries where innovation, customer service, and employee retention are paramount, this style can lead to high engagement and morale, and sustained growth.

Challenges During Crisis

However, the servant leadership model, with its emphasis on consensus and collaboration, lacks the decisiveness required in crisis situations. In times of significant turmoil—be it a sudden market downturn, a corporate scandal, or geopolitical instability—what’s often required is clear, authoritative decision-making. In these ‘wartime’ scenarios, leaders might need to adopt a more directive approach to navigate through challenges effectively.

Wartime Leadership: Necessity of Command and Control

In contrast to peacetime leadership, wartime leadership demands a high level of assertiveness and the ability to make tough decisions quickly, often with limited input from others. This might include making unpopular decisions such as budget cuts, layoffs, or drastic changes in strategy. The wartime leader needs to act with conviction and authority, rallying the organization to face imminent threats head-on.

Balancing Leadership Styles

It’s essential for leaders to recognize the context in which they are operating and adjust their leadership style accordingly. The most effective leaders are those who can toggle between being a servant leader during times of stability and a wartime leader during crises. This adaptability is crucial not only for surviving adverse conditions but also for thriving in a competitive landscape.

Developing Adaptive Leadership Skills

For current and aspiring leaders, developing a flexible leadership style is key. This involves:

  • Self-awareness: Understanding your natural leadership tendencies and recognizing when a shift is needed.
  • Situational awareness: Being able to read the external and internal environment to determine the most effective style at any given time.
  • Communication skills: Clearly and effectively conveying changes in leadership approach to ensure team alignment.
  • Decision-making capabilities: Strengthening the ability to make quick, informed decisions especially under pressure.

In conclusion, while servant leadership has many virtues, it’s not a one-size-fits-all solution. Effective leadership, especially in times of crisis, often requires a more directive, assertive approach. By embracing the concept of ‘horses for courses,’ leaders can ensure they are not just good but great, by being exactly what their organization needs, when it needs it.

Do you want to learn how AI can be practically applied across HR? If so, sign up for my brand new online course Applying AI in HR: A Practical Guide for HR Professionals. Get straightforward insights into leveraging AI across all HR domains.

Also, explore my international bestselling books:

Check out my podcast, “A Practical Guide to…” available on:

Thank you for your support.